Too German for Holocaust Research?

Alfred Wiener and Louis de Jong on the Institut für Zeitgeschichte, 1952

In October 1952, Alfred Wiener and Louis de Jong compared notes on the still relatively new Institute for Contemporary History in Munich (Institut für Zeitgeschichte, IfZ), wondering whether its staff members would be capable of conducting research on National Socialism. While non-Jewish German researchers claimed that Jews were too preoccupied with and emotional about the Holocaust, these two Jewish researchers raised questions concerning the Germans’ political affiliations. 

Continue reading Too German for Holocaust Research?

Britain’s View of the German Cult of the Dead: A Media History Perspective

In September 1943, at a time when the Second World War was turning into a military debacle for the German Wehrmacht, the Leicester Evening Mail published an article entitled ‘The New German Valhalla: Nazis’ Pagan Cult of Death’. In it, the author analysed the current state of German wartime society and focused in particular on the central importance of the cult of death in German warfare:

Understand Germany’s morbid addiction to the Nibelungenlied, and you will understand also Germany’s official mood after Stalingrad, when for weeks the radio played funeral marches and newspapers, newsreels and Nazi speakers wallowed in a revolting orgy of death, morbidity and shameless self-pity . . . This sadistic longing for the ‘glorious’ and universal death is a dangerous element in the German make-up we must not forget, however much we may despise it . . . Everything that comes out of Germany these days reveals that the cult of death and immolation is spreading in the Reich . . . But perhaps, with bombs raining from the skies in ever-increasing volume . . . the Germans may yet learn that death is far from sweet and glorious even under a tyrant of their own making.1

The article is primarily an example of the journalistic observations and characterizations of the military enemy that were regularly published in British newspapers during the war. A special feature of the text, however, is its precise analysis of the German cult of death and sacrifice. The military successes and fighting morale of the Wehrmacht were not only dependent on military strategy, manpower, and advanced weapons, but also on the ideological and propagandistic influence exerted on German soldiers. Particularly in the second half of the Second World War, when the phase of quick and successful blitzkrieg was over, specific strategies were needed to motivate soldiers to fight in a war that was increasingly hopeless, and also to legitimize the high number of victims. In this respect, the cult of the dead played a special role in Nazi propaganda. One element of these strategies was the promise that the deaths of soldiers who had given their lives to preserve the German Volksgemeinschaft (the Nazi ideal of the racially unified society in which individual interests were subordinate to those of the nation) would be afforded the highest heroic honour. The article in the Leicester Evening Mail therefore rightly emphasizes the danger and military consequences of German soldiers’ tendency towards fatalism and fanaticism.

Despite its contemporary journalistic perspective, the text addresses two remarkable aspects that touch on historical research into the National Socialist death cult and its propaganda. First, the history of National Socialism is not only a history of mass killing, but also of mass death. Over time, the society of the Third Reich was confronted with the deaths of countless people, but also—especially in a military context—with a willingness to sacrifice and die. While contemporary perceptions of National Socialism and historical research have focused primarily on investigating German soldiers’ willingness to kill, examination of their willingness to sacrifice and die—which was regularly demanded of them in political, ideological, and military contexts—has tended to take a back seat.2

Second, the Nazi cult of the dead has so far been analysed primarily from the perspective of national historiography in the context of examining the Nazi dictatorship.  The focus has mainly been on annual commemoration days in the Third Reich, monuments to fallen soldiers, and the commemorative work of the NSDAP and its propaganda institutions. For all its diversity, however, this research has remained confined to a national context and has barely taken into account the foreign reception of the National Socialist cult of the dead.3

Image of an article from the daily newspaper Hallische Nachrichten, 11 March 1939, covering Heldengedenktag (Heroes' Memorial Day)
Fig. 1: Extract from an article on Heldengedenktag (Heroes’ Memorial Day) in the daily newspaper Hallische Nachrichten, 11 March 1939.
Credit: Provided by the Universitäts- und Landesbibliothek Halle

Project Focus

A media history perspective, as I am pursuing in my current research project on ‘Dying and Death as a Media Event: A Media History of Heroic Sacrificial Death, 1930–1950’, not only concentrates on media representations of the commemoration of the dead (which have so far been only partially investigated), but also reveals the transnational scope of the topic. The Reich Propaganda Ministry and its subordinate Deutsches Nachrichtenbüro, the official German news agency, always sought to feed reports and material about the commemoration of the dead in the Third Reich into the global news agency network. The foreign media work of Nazi organizations ensured therefore that the Nazi propaganda about dead heroes and the fundamental significance of their heroic sacrifice was not only consumed within the borders of the Reich but also attracted global media attention.

There are two main reasons why it seems obvious and productive to look in particular at German–British media relations when analysing the transnational media reception of Germany’s commemoration of the dead. For one thing, even before the twentieth century, Germany and Great Britain had a long history of close media relations, characterized by intensive exchange and mutual influence.4 For another, the media relations between the two countries intensified once again during the world wars, as a result of which mutual observation and reception reached a new level of intensity. The specific relationship between the two countries during the Second World War, characterized by political hostility and military threat, played a decisive role here, and this was also reflected in their respective national propaganda policies. The history of German–British relations is therefore a useful backdrop for an investigation of the British media’s external perception of German propaganda policy during the Second World War and, consequently, of the National Socialist death cult.5

As the aforecited example in the Leicester Evening Mail shows, the National Socialist commemoration of the dead and the idea of heroic sacrifice were closely observed and thematized in the British media. British daily newspapers regularly published articles reporting on commemorative rituals in Germany, sometimes in great detail, and quoting extracts from political speeches given on such occasions. In addition to foreign correspondence, which was mainly based on agency reports, there were also numerous commentary articles in which the National Socialist cult of the dead was viewed with distanced fascination, disconcertment, disdain, or undisguised amusement. This reveals a twofold media interest on the British side: the memorial days of the Third Reich were fundamentally both political and propagandistic events. In particular, the commemorative speeches held on these occasions by high-ranking representatives of the Nazi regime usually included major political or military announcements that were always relevant to foreign reportage and were therefore regularly watched, or listened to, by British correspondents.

In addition, the intense media observation from the British side was based on a specific fascination. Because the Nazi death cult, with its highly symbolic and militaristic staging, was an especially publicly visible part of Nazi propaganda, it naturally attracted foreign interest. British commentators and correspondents often described it as an absurd or macabre spectacle. However, they were attentive to these productions precisely because they believed them to be an authentic and vivid expression of National Socialist ideology. This fascination and disconcertment was further enhanced during the war by the fact that British politicians and military staff associated the constant thematization of heroic self-sacrifice with the morale of German soldiers. In this respect, it was important for them to observe the media presence of this ideological narrative, as it had direct relevance for the strategic planning of the British military’s psychological warfare and propaganda.6

Archival Work

During my six-week stay as a scholarship holder at the GHI London in October and November 2023, I was able to examine numerous sources in archives and libraries to gain insight into the presence and reception of the Nazi death cult in British media, as well as evaluations of and reactions to it by political and military actors in Great Britain. Of particular importance to me was my research at The National Archives in Kew, where I examined documents from the Ministry of Information, the War Office, and the War Cabinet containing memoranda, analyses, and evaluations of German and British propaganda activities. The material forms a basis for considering the transnational perception and evaluation of the German cult of the dead in my study, and, with its decidedly external perspective, also contributes to a more profound understanding of German propaganda activities.

Featured image: Heldengedenktag (Heroes’ Memorial Day) ceremony in Berlin on 25 February 1934. Credit: Bundesarchiv, Bild 183-H25366 / CC-BY-SA 3.0 

  1. ‘The New German Valhalla: Nazis’ Pagan Cult of Death’, Leicester Evening Mail, 22 Sept. 1943, 3. []
  2. See Michael Geyer, ‘Eine Kriegsgeschichte, die vom Tod spricht’, in Thomas Lindenberger and Alf Lüdtke (eds.), Physische Gewalt: Studien zur Geschichte der Neuzeit (Frankfurt am Main, 1995), 136–61. []
  3. See Sabine Behrenbeck, Der Kult um die toten Helden: Nationalsozialistische Mythen, Riten und Symbole 1923 bis 1945, 2nd edn. (Cologne, 2011); Alexandra Kaiser, Von Helden und Opfern: Eine Geschichte des Volkstrauertags (Frankfurt am Main, 2010); Jay W. Baird, To Die for Germany: Heroes in the Nazi Pantheon (Bloomington, IN, 1990); Alon Confino, Paul Betts, and Dirk Schumann (eds.), Between Mass Death and Individual Loss: The Place of the Dead in Twentieth-Century Germany (New York, 2008); and, recently published, Jesús Casquete, Politics of Death: The Cult of Nazi Martyrs, 1920–1939 (New York, 2023). []
  4. See, with numerous further references, Frank Bösch, ‘Zwischen Populärkultur und Politik: Britische und deutsche Printmedien im 19. Jahrhundert’, Archiv für Sozialgeschichte, 45 (2005), 549–84; Dominik Geppert, Pressekriege: Öffentlichkeit und Diplomatie in den deutsch-britischen Beziehungen (1896–1912) (Munich, 2007), and Frank Bösch and Dominik Geppert (eds.), Journalists as Political Actors: Transfers and Interactions between Britain and Germany since the Late 19th Century (Augsburg, 2008). []
  5. See Thomas Wittek, Auf ewig Feind? Das Deutschlandbild in den britischen Massenmedien nach dem Ersten Weltkrieg (Munich, 2005); and Nelson Ribeiro and Stephanie Seul (eds.), Revisiting Transnational Broadcasting: The BBC’s Foreign-Language Services during the Second World War (London, 2017). []
  6. See Christian Götter, Die Macht der Wirkungsannahmen: Medienarbeit des britischen und deutschen Militärs in der ersten Hälfte des 20. Jahrhunderts (Berlin, 2016); Falko Bell, Britische Feindaufklärung im Zweiten Weltkrieg: Stellenwert und Wirkung der ‘Human Intelligence’ in der britischen Kriegsführung 1939–1945 (Paderborn, 2016); Michael Balfour, Propaganda in War, 1939–1945: Organisations, Policies and Publics in Britain and Germany (London, 1979). []

‘Political Balance’ or ‘Natural Growth’? The British Mandate, Meir Dizengoff, and the Struggle over Tel Aviv Port in the 1920s and 1930s

On 24 February 1938, a crowd of 30,000 onlookers gathered in the rain awaiting the official opening of Tel Aviv port to passenger traffic. Due to bad weather conditions, however, the ceremony had been moved inside a ‘gaily decorated warehouse’ on the shore of the Mediterranean in the north of the ‘first Hebrew city’. To make matters worse, the rough seas prevented the landing of passengers at Tel Aviv port on that day, and the SS Har Tsiyon had to be redirected to Haifa.1

Yet such adverse conditions did little to dampen the Tel Avivians’ celebratory mood. The city’s port had been a project long in the making, and it held great significance not only for Tel Aviv, but for the Zionist project as a whole. Although long disregarded by a historiography focused on the Zionist ‘return to the land’, visions and schemes of a maritime revival—as part of national self-fulfilment and realization—were an integral part of Zionist thought.

Continue reading ‘Political Balance’ or ‘Natural Growth’? The British Mandate, Meir Dizengoff, and the Struggle over Tel Aviv Port in the 1920s and 1930s
  1. ‘New “Gateway to Zion” Inaugurated’, Palestine Post, 24 Feb. 1938, 1; ‘Tel Aviv—Sha‘ar Tsyion, Derekh Ba Ya‘avru ha-Ge‘ulim’, ha-Arets, 24 Feb. 1938, 1. []

Visualizing Labour in German East Africa: Photographic Images and their Circulation

Thirty years ago, in 1993, Cambridge University Library acquired a substantial quantity of materials from the Commonwealth and Britain’s former colonial territories. This repository originally came from the Colonial Society, which over the decades became the Royal Colonial Institute, then the Royal Empire Society, and finally the Royal Commonwealth Society (RCS).1 This institution had begun collecting and archiving these documents around 1868, when it received funding to rent a suite in the Westminster Palace Hotel, and did so more intensively after 1900, as the collection grew and moved to larger premises. By the time the RCS library was integrated into the special collections of Cambridge University Library, it housed extensive and invaluable archives, including ancient texts in cuneiform script dating back to around 2200 BCE, as well as documents from the twentieth century.2 Among the latter were ten boxes of postcards from different regions of the former British Empire, printed between 1890 and 1969.3

Continue reading Visualizing Labour in German East Africa: Photographic Images and their Circulation
  1. See the history of the Royal Commonwealth Society (RCS) collection, (accessed 5 Jan. 2024). []
  2. See the RCS Library, (accessed 5 Jan. 2024). []
  3. Cambridge University Library, GBR/0115/RCS/PC, Postcard Collection. []

The Welsh Fasting Girl: A Morbid Spectacle

The story of Sarah Jacob is a tragic one.1 On 17 December 1869, when she was not yet 13 years old, she died of starvation. There was no shortage of food or unwillingness to provide her with food, had she asked for it. Her family, trained nurses, and male doctors were around her when she passed away, but they all quite literally watched her die.

Continue reading The Welsh Fasting Girl: A Morbid Spectacle
  1. E.g. ‘The drama of the Welsh fasting girl […] has ended tragically’. Anon., ‘The Week. Topics of the Day’, The Medical Times and Gazette, 25 Dec. 1869, 738 (my emphases); ‘The second act of the Carmarthen Tragedy has been played out’. Anon., No Title, The Western Mail, 27 Dec. 1869, 2. []

‘No Shows’ and Other Forms of Refusal: Reading Missionary Letters about the Loyalty Islands

As part of my PhD study, I am investigating and tracing the history of the island communities of the Ruapuke Mission Station in the Foveaux Strait in southern New Zealand and of the Loyalty Islands north-east of New Caledonia.

Continue reading ‘No Shows’ and Other Forms of Refusal: Reading Missionary Letters about the Loyalty Islands

Competition between Profit and Principles: The ‘Natural’ Market Niche in 1980s Britain

Below are findings that are part of my research for my doctoral thesis on the entanglement of commercial business and moral responsibility in the 1970s and 1980s. My access to archives across England, and specifically London, was made possible by the opportunity to stay at the German Historical Institute London in July and August 2023. In particular, the Walgreens Boots Alliance Archive in Nottingham and the Victoria and Albert Museum in London provided me with relevant sources.

Continue reading Competition between Profit and Principles: The ‘Natural’ Market Niche in 1980s Britain

Trial and Error: The Federal Republic of Germany’s Failed First National Day of Remembrance and Where to Go from There

On 7 September 1950, the improvised West German parliamentary building—the Bundeshaus in Bonn—was packed with people. The Federal Chancellor with his cabinet, the majority of both chambers of parliament, as well as a significant number of honorary guests from high society had come together for the first ‘National Day of Remembrance of the German People’ (Nationaler Gedenktag des deutschen Volkes). Even the Allied High Commissioners were there.1

Continue reading Trial and Error: The Federal Republic of Germany’s Failed First National Day of Remembrance and Where to Go from There
  1. See C. E. L., ‘Ein Tag wie jeder andere’, Die Zeit, 7 Sept. 1950, at [], accessed 12 June 2023. []

Philip Quaque in Cape Coast 1766–1816

Cape Coast Castle is one of more than thirty forts which European trading companies erected on the coast of modern-day Ghana between the fifteenth and the nineteenth century. The castle has long been a symbol of one of the most heinous crimes in history: the Atlantic slave trade. Visitors who tour the building in the twenty-first century often project their feelings of anger, grief, and regret onto the inert structure. Some of them are even convinced that spirits roam the slave dungeons, courtyards, and parapets.1 One of these spirits is the Reverend Philip Quaque, the first person of African descent to ever be ordained in the Anglican Church. Quaque is buried in the fort’s courtyard under a couple of stone slabs bearing his initials. His story, or at least a version of it, features in every guided tour.2

Continue reading Philip Quaque in Cape Coast 1766–1816
  1. Bayo Holsey, Routes of Remembrance: Refashioning the Slave Trade in Ghana (Chicago and London, 2008), 151–95. []
  2. Ibid. 186–7. []

Sing a Line with Coca Wine: The European Rediscovery of Coca

‘Cocaine flashed like a meteor before the eyes of the medical world.’1

The discovery of cocaine turned out to be an exceptional novelty in the medicinal and pharmaceutical world of the late nineteenth century but the history of the raw material of the drug, however, went far back in the originating countries. For millennia, coca had been the ‘sacred plant of the Inca’, who regarded it as a gift from the gods, and their priests used it first and foremost in ancient rituals.2 There was a brief caesura in the use of coca when the conquistadores considered coca consumption an indigenous vice, but they soon changed their minds, and the habit spread among all social classes and became a cultural marker for the native population.3 The drug enjoyed popularity in western South America due to it alleviating altitude sickness in the Andes and suppressing hunger, but it also had pain-relieving properties.4 Convinced by the plant’s marvellous effects on the human body, the conquistadores contemplated the introduction of coca into the European market, but they failed in their plan because of underdeveloped means of transport and a lack of knowledge about proper storage, which impacted coca’s potency.

Continue reading Sing a Line with Coca Wine: The European Rediscovery of Coca
  1. ‘Cocaine’, Chambers’s Journal of Popular Literature, Science, and Art, 3/114 (6 March 1886), 147. []
  2. Joseph Acosta, The Naturall and Morall Historie of the East and West Indies, trans. E. G. (London, 1604), 273; Joseph Kennedy, Coca Exotica. The Illustrated Story of Cocaine (London, 1985), p. x. []
  3. ‘Some Popular Remedies’, Chambers’s Journal of Popular Literature, Science and Art, 12/577 (19 January 1895), 44; Kennedy, Coca Exotica, 15, 26, 27. []
  4. J. J. von Tschudi, Travels in Peru, During the Years 1838–1842, on the Coast, in the Sierra, across the Cordilleras and the Andes, into the Primeval Forests, trans. Thomasina Ross (London, 1847), 452, 453, 454. []
Search OpenEdition Search

You will be redirected to OpenEdition Search